INCLINE VILLAGE, Calif. – The Incline Village General Improvement District Board voted to put in a $2.3 million offer to purchase the old elementary school from Tahoe Transportation District at Wednesday’s meeting.
TTD is currently looking to transfer the property to Reno Housing Authority at no cost to build a transit-oriented affordable housing complex.
The offer is the latest in a years-long saga of how to use the land parcel, located at 771 Southwood Blvd in the center of Incline Village, since Washoe County School District closed the elementary school in 2010. IVGID previously declined to purchase the property in 2019 when the school district offered.
IVGID’s current offer does not guarantee that TTD will accept it. But if IVGID is successful in its purchase, the district would use the property as its new administrative building, replacing its current aging building that will soon need costly repairs.
IVGID is also proposing building a mixed-use development with workforce housing that has higher income caps than the RHA proposal or using it as a community center, depending on future public input.
However, nothing in the drafted contract requires IVGID to build any housing on the property once it is in its possession. The word “housing” never appears in the proposed contract.
“We could go through this process and the board may ultimately decide just to keep it as a part of our recreational inventory, and that’s always an option, too,” District General Manager Robert Harrison said during the meeting.
The contract only says that IVGID is an eligible local government entity that “desires to acquire and use the property for the public purpose of constructing a new public administration complex and village center.” In a presentation at the meeting, this “village center” was described as a “housing and commercial development supporting a walkable community gathering space.”
The board voted 4-1 to authorize staff to submit an offer to TTD, with Trustee Ray Tulloch dissenting. Tulloch said he voted no because he thinks the district is incapable of running projects profitably without large subsidies, which other trustees disputed.
In 2021, the school district sold the elementary school site to TTD, despite opposition, to use as a “mobility hub,” and a year later TTD faced an appeal to stop its use for transit due to complaints about traffic congestion, cars parking illegally and litter.
The appeal was denied, but now TTD says the hub is no longer viable and it hopes to offload the property.
Why does IVGID want the property? Mostly, control.
District General Manager Harrison gave a presentation on and expressed his support for the proposed purchase to the board. He said the primary benefit of the purchase would be the building’s use as the district’s new administrative building.
“Through ownership of the property, we control the redevelopment outcome,” Harrison said. “I think that’s the most critical thing.”
Board Chair Michaela Tonking said that there has not been public input in the TTD’s decision to give the property to the RHA and asked staff to confirm that there would be ample community outreach on what to do with the property if IVGID were successful in purchasing it.
Board Treasurer Mick Homan said the property is “critically important” and purchasing it would ensure it doesn’t fall into the hands of “an outside agency that isn’t as vested in the health of our community.”
He added that if the land is transferred to the RHA, the district’s “opportunity to influence or control the outcome will be lost forever.”
Reno Housing Authority’s proposal and IVGID’s objections
If RHA were to acquire the property, it would find a developer to build 150 federally subsidized units that are subject to federal affordable housing regulations.
RHA’s proposal includes between 105 and 120 units restricted to tenants who make at or below 60% of Washoe County’s area median income. For a single person, that income cap is $49,080. For a family of four, that would be limited to a combined income of $70,080.
Of those units, between 8.5 and 12 of them would be for extremely low income individuals that make up to 30% AMI, which is $24,550 for one person and $35,050 for a family of four.
Between 30 and 45 units would fall under the designation of attainable or workforce housing, which would cap incomes at or below 80% AMI.
Multiple trustees argued there aren’t enough people who make below these income levels already in Incline Village to fill these units. They said that IVGID hopes to build attainable workforce housing that would allow tenants who make up to 150% AMI.
Vice Chair Michelle Jezycki repeatedly referenced an affordable housing complex in Truckee with similar income requirements, Coldstream Commons. She said there weren’t enough locals that fit the income requirements for Coldstream, and the developer had to fill vacancies with people from Sacramento, a last resort she would hope to avoid in Incline.
The Tribune could not immediately verify this claim.
Jezycki emphasized the need for workforce housing that professionals in the community could qualify for.
“Having Incline control its redevelopment is, I think, a huge factor for us, for our community,” she said. “Rather than having things done to us, supposedly on our behalf, especially when these figures show us that this will not meet the need we so desperately need.”
During his presentation, Harrison showed a chart of IVGID’s own employees and under what AMI’s they would fall. He noted that only 21 of the district’s employees make below 50% AMI. It is unclear how many employees would qualify who make between 50% and 60% AMI, as the next tier in the chart is 80% AMI or below.
If that income cap went up to 150% AMI, as IVGID’s theoretical proposal would allow, then 790 of IVGID’s employees would qualify for the housing, including the 21 people who make below 50%, according to Harrison’s chart. None of IVGID’s employees make at or below 30% AMI.
Homan said because working professionals in Incline wouldn’t qualify for the low, federally-dictated income caps in the RHA’s proposal, it would cause an increase in commuters, rather than a decrease.
He also said that Incline does not have the social services necessary to support a low income population such as transportation, health care access and more.
Board Chair Michaela Tonking agreed that Incline doesn’t have the social services infrastructure, noting a lack of support from Washoe County. Tonking said this lack “makes me very nervous for what RHA is proposing.”
Jezycki also voiced fears about public safety that, when examined further, were unsubstantiated.
She claimed that the Truckee development Coldstream Commons was evidence that RHA’s development will only bring problems to Incline. To back this up, she inaccurately cited grievances from a petition that Truckee residents formed against a homeless shelter that is nearby Coldstream Commons but in no way affiliated with it.
Her claims included that the affordable housing complex caused a “severe increase” in police activity and that residents witnessed threats against local employees, public intoxication and drug use, theft, trespassing, loitering, public defecation, littering and adverse impacts on nearby local businesses due to the complex.
All of these grievances were against Truckee Navigation Center, a homeless shelter in the Coldstream neighborhood. At least one resident of Coldstream Commons signed the petition against the shelter.
The only mention of Coldstream Commons in the petition is of “issues when the residents of both locations are interfacing” and how moving the homeless shelter would decrease interactions and police calls.
“The train has left the station”
Even though IVGID is submitting an offer for purchase, there’s no guarantee that TTD will accept it, and more than one board member was pessimistic about their chances.
Harrison emphasized that TTD did not reach out to IVGID about the property and made no effort to solicit any offers from the district at the beginning of his presentation. Washoe County submitted a letter to TTD in support of the RHA development plan, citing “a severe shortage of below‑market and workforce‑level units.”
IVGID’s lawyer suggested the board authorize him and Harrison to talk directly with the Federal Transit Administration — which gave TTD the original grant money to purchase the property and thus dictates the purchase conditions through federal law — if TTD didn’t seriously consider the district’s offer.
This authorization was added to the final motion that passed.
Because TTD is further along in the RHA deal and didn’t demonstrate interest in receiving an offer from IVGID, those at the district said they are not expecting much.
Jezycki called the RHA transfer “probably a done deal.”
“There’s been something that just seemed off to me from the get go,” Jezycki said. “The analogy I come up with is that the train has left the station, but some time ago, and we weren’t even offered to board.”
