Motorboats versus Swimmers: Paying the Price of Human Pace

I am a regular open water swimmer in Donner Lake and Lake Tahoe. All summer, I relish the tranquility I find with my head under the surface, slowly stroking my way through the cold, clear water. For me, the feeling of being immersed in nature, moving at a human pace, and being propelled by the work of my own body is unbeatable. Since I began swimming as a young child, I have loved the way being underwater dampens the sounds from the world above. The underwater world of my family’s backyard pool felt private and protective. In the early morning on calm, uncrowded days in Donner, the water can be so smooth its surface reflects the tall pines that rim the lake. My connection with the lake and the other open-water swimmers feels intimate. We often exchange pleasantries and everyone talks about the same things. “The water was so beautiful and calm today, the sky was almost too blue.” Acquaintances ask each other, “How far did you swim today?”

On many days, however, the tranquility I seek is interrupted by fast-moving power boats and jet skis. The smooth swim stroke that I have worked for years to improve feels like it gets toppled in the boats’ wakes. I avoid lake swimming on summer weekends and holidays because of the crowds. I have grudgingly accepted that swimming in the lake means putting up with the noise, rough water, and pollution they create. The boats usually stick to deep waters further from shore, so their impact on my swim is usually brief. I wear a bright orange cap and a buoy, stick to the shoreline, and hope that boaters notice me and don’t run me over. These small items are my only defense against their dangerous motors and propellers.

I read the recent article in Moonshine Ink about the emerging popularity of foiling in Tahoe/Truckee. The article lauded the foil athletes for the risks they take in the name of being on the frontier of a new sport. However, the article made no mention of the risks and disruptions foilers impose on other sports and the people who enjoy them. The past two summers I have noticed an increase in foilers, particularly the electric type, on our lakes. These foil boards dart around very quickly and often stay closer to the shore than the power boats. I have observed electric foils zipping around areas where there are many paddleboards, kayaks, children on floats, and swimmers. I often worry about getting hit by their sharp fins or propellers, and they make a particularly annoying high-pitched sound underwater when they are nearby. It is easy to see that foiling seems thrilling and challenging, but should the adrenaline rush of the foilers, speed boaters, and jet skiers override the peace and safety that lake swimmers, kayakers, paddle boarders, and floaters deserve?

Every new motorized toy people choose to buy and use adds to the burden they place on our lakes, and on other people’s experience in the water. People who enjoy our environment in low-impact, human-powered ways (swimming, hiking, or running) are disproportionately and negatively affected by those choosing high-impact activities, especially on small lakes. Lake Tahoe is large enough to accommodate many more and diverse users. Donner is so small that power boats, jet skis, and foils create outsized impacts on people and the environment. I wish Moonshine Ink had taken this perspective into consideration before publishing an article touting the excitement of foiling.

~ Wendy Lair has been a part-time and later full-time resident of Truckee since 2013. She is a psychotherapist in private practice, the mother of one fantastic 17-year-old daughter and two small, water-hating dogs. She regularly indulges in her love of swimming (obviously), cross country skiing, hiking,  and Pilates.